Understanding Traffic Policing and Traffic Shaping in Computer Networks

• Traffic Policing: This mechanism monitors data flows and enforces bandwidth limits by discarding or marking packets that exceed the defined threshold. It’s like a security guard that stops traffic if it gets too heavy.
• Traffic Shaping: Rather than dropping packets, shaping delays traffic by queuing excess packets and releasing them at a steady rate. This process smooths out traffic to conform to desired bandwidth patterns, which is especially useful for delay-sensitive applications.

In real-world networks, both techniques are employed together to regulate flow and avoid congestion, improving the overall performance and reliability of internet communication.

Why Do We Need These Mechanisms?

Networks handle diverse types of data—video streaming, voice calls, emails, and more. Each type of data has different QoS requirements in terms of latency, jitter, and packet loss. Traffic shaping and policing ensure these requirements are met by:

• Controlling traffic flow to prevent bottlenecks.
• Ensuring fair bandwidth distribution among users.
• Enhancing user experience for critical services like VoIP or online gaming.

Given the difficulty of maintaining a constant bit rate across routers and links in a typical network, traffic regulation mechanisms provide a structured approach to managing variability and spikes in data transmission.

The Leaky Bucket Algorithm: A Traffic Control Pioneer

Conceptual Analogy

Imagine a bucket with a small hole at the bottom. Water (packets) is poured into the bucket (queue) and leaks out at a constant rate. If water is added too quickly and the bucket overflows, the excess spills out (packet loss).

How It Works

• Incoming packets are stored in a queue with limited capacity (τ).
• The server (or the output link) removes packets from this queue at a fixed rate (r).
• If packets arrive faster than they are sent and exceed the bucket capacity, the extra packets are dropped.

This constant rate output is great for smoothing traffic. The algorithm ensures that packets are transmitted uniformly, reducing traffic spikes that can cause congestion.

Dual Role

• Traffic Policing: By limiting the queue size, any packet that arrives after the queue is full is dropped.
• Traffic Shaping: The consistent output rate ensures a smoothed traffic flow, preventing sudden surges.

Real-World Implication

The leaky bucket is particularly useful when you need to enforce a hard rate limit. However, it does not allow for bursty traffic—even if the network was idle moments before, it can't transmit packets faster than the fixed rate.

The Token Bucket Algorithm: Supporting Bursty Traffic

Conceptual Overview

Instead of pouring water, imagine tokens being dropped into a bucket at a steady rate (r tokens/sec). Each token grants permission to send one packet (or a specific number of bytes). When a packet arrives:

• If a token is available, it’s consumed, and the packet is transmitted.
• If no token is available, the packet waits or gets dropped.

Key Components

• Token Generation Rate (r): Defines how many tokens are added per second.
• Bucket Size (b): The maximum number of tokens that can be stored. This directly influences how large a burst can be.
• Packet Queue: Stores incoming packets waiting for available tokens.

Main Advantage: Burstiness Support

Suppose no packets arrive for a while; tokens continue to accumulate. Later, if a sudden burst of data arrives, it can be sent immediately using the stored tokens, enabling a burst transmission—something the leaky bucket doesn’t support.

This makes token bucket ideal for applications where traffic patterns are irregular but need high-speed data transmission during certain intervals (e.g., video streaming buffers, software updates).

Token Bucket vs. Leaky Bucket: A Comparison

Both algorithms aim to control the output traffic rate but in very different ways. Leaky bucket enforces strict traffic flow, while token bucket offers room for optimization and flexibility, especially in real-time data transmission scenarios.

Estimating Maximum Burst Size in Token Bucket

The maximum burst size (MBS) defines how many packets can be sent at once during a traffic spike. It’s calculated based on the token bucket’s size and generation rate.

Given:

• P = Incoming packet rate
• r = Token generation rate
• b = Initial bucket size

We calculate the time until the bucket runs out of tokens during a burst:

t₁ = b / (P - r)

Then, the maximum number of packets that can be sent during this burst is:

MBS = P × t₁ = (Pb) / (P - r)

This mathematical model is critical for designing systems that can anticipate traffic bursts and handle them effectively.

Application Example: Buffered Video Streaming

In streaming services like YouTube or Netflix, data is often downloaded faster than it’s consumed. The token bucket algorithm supports this by allowing bursts when tokens are available, thus filling the playout buffer quickly. Once the buffer has enough data, the stream can play without interruptions, even if data arrives later at a slower rate.

This approach provides a smoother user experience and reduces buffering issues—one of the many reasons token bucket algorithms are widely adopted in multimedia networks.

Enhancing Traffic Smoothing: The Role of Playout Buffers

In situations where even token bucket shaping leads to dips due to irregular packet generation from applications, a playout buffer can be introduced.

• Purpose: To delay early packets just enough so that the entire stream can be played out at a constant rate.
• Result: A smoother playback or data consumption experience, especially beneficial for real-time streaming or VoIP.

This shows that sometimes a combination of token bucket shaping and playout buffering is used to achieve near-ideal traffic smoothing.

Conclusion

Traffic policing and shaping are vital techniques in modern networking, ensuring that bandwidth is used efficiently and fairly. Understanding the leaky bucket and token bucket algorithms provides foundational knowledge to build more responsive and reliable network services.

• Leaky bucket is simple and enforces strict rate limits, ideal for consistent traffic control.
• Token bucket is flexible, supports bursts, and is better suited for variable traffic patterns.

As the internet continues to evolve with more real-time applications, adaptive traffic regulation strategies will remain critical. Whether you are optimizing QoS in a network infrastructure or preparing for your networking exams, mastering these concepts is essential.

Need help with your networking coursework or assignments? Our team of experts at computer network assignment help is here to guide you with customized, high-quality solutions tailored to your academic needs.